Men’s Sport Penny: Made to Order

Rated 4.2 out of 5
Based on 55 reviews
$299.00 USD
Return Policy

Custom (Made To Order) products are personalized based on your design choices and, therefore, not returnable for refund or exchange (unless there is a defect in material or craftsmanship of the product). We want you to love your new custom footwear purchase as much as we enjoy handcrafting them for you so if you are not 100% satisfied with your custom order, we will quickly address your concern. Please contact service@quoddy.com or call (207) 853-2488 to discuss how we can help correct any issues. Most of the time issues are with fit and many of those be resolved and we will gladly work to adjust the fit for you: Of course, it’s best to minimize any fit issues ahead of your purchase so click on this link to see our fit guide or feel free to call customer service for direction ahead of time and we will help walk you through the process. For more information on our return policy, please visit this link.

average rating 4.2 out of 5
Based on 55 reviews
  • 5 Stars
    37 Reviews
  • 4 Stars
    8 Reviews
  • 3 Stars
    2 Reviews
  • 2 Stars
    2 Reviews
  • 1 Star
    6 Reviews
82% of reviewers would recommend this product to a friend
55 Reviews
Reviewed by William A.
Verified Buyer
I recommend this product
Rated 5 out of 5
Review posted

Great Shoes

Very comfortable, easy break-in. Nice workmanship. This is my 5th pair of Quoddy’s

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by Andrew T.
Verified Buyer
I don't recommend this product
Rated 1 out of 5
Review posted

Bad fit

No way that last is a double e. Way to narrow in the instep I should have had you make a eee or even a 4e .

.

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by Andrew A.
Verified Buyer
I don't recommend this product
Rated 2 out of 5
Review posted

Quality is apparent but be careful on sizing

Don’t make the mistake of making your first pair of Quoddys an MTO like I did. You need to be sure of your size because these can’t be exchanged. I normally wear size 9 in Sperrys so I used that as a guide and just to be safe I sized up half a size. I was still off. I would have been better off with a size 10 but the bigger problem is the width. D width is too tight. Needed to be an E. I don’t think I’ll be able to wear these and it’s too bad because they’re great looking shoes.

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by MUSTAPHA EL K.
Verified Buyer
I recommend this product
Rated 5 out of 5
Review posted

Highly recommended !

Super Confort and perfect size.

Superb quality and materials.

I like also the color is very very nice (dark brown, black saddle leather with camp sole brick)

All good leather quality.

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Reviewed by William M.
Verified Buyer
I don't recommend this product
Rated 1 out of 5
Review posted

Bad fit, wrong color, low quality

The leather colors on the website are completely different from how they look in reality. As a result, I ended up with a bad looking leather / sole color combo. Also, the shoes run extremely narrow and don’t fit my feet at all. I have worn them several times now trying to break them in and stretch them out, with no progres. They also give me blisters on my heels every time I wear them. I completely regret buying them and will probably throw them away.

Loading...
Was this helpful?
Subscribe To

Quoddy News

×